Any show making it to Broadway is something of a miracle, let alone an original musical. Wanted, formerly titled Gun & Powder, seemingly comes at the perfect time as the first new musical to open this season. A true story hook promises racial dynamics and saucy sisters on the run. An ensemble cast overflowing with black talent—and Grammy nominees!—should have made Wanted an outstanding must-see. Instead, this clunky, oddly-staged misfire is mostly a snooze. Messy staging, forgettable music, and inconsistent acting rob Wanted of any chance to make Broadway history.

An immersive theatre complete with twangy music and a silhouette-driven wanted poster covering the stage already sets the mood even before the curtain rises. It’s Texas in 1893. Black twin sisters Mary (Solea Pfeiffer) and Martha (Liisi LaFontaine) Clarke and their mother (Ledisi) have saved up enough money to buy land from the awful Mr. Billingsley (Nathan Quay Thomas). There’s just one little problem: they spill the plan too early. Billingsley promptly raises their rent so they’ll have to deplete every bit of money they’ve earned cotton picking and then some. The cruel realities faced by black folks during this time period are nakedly displayed in this cutting opening that evokes a very similar tone to Todrick Hall’s Midnight. If only the same could be said of the rest of the nearly two-and-a-half hour musical.
Determined to escape their fates, white-passing sisters Mary and Martha decide to try actually being white for a change. They are so convincing that men mistake them for pathetic women. Once they quickly realize the power they have with just a revolver in tow, the sisters blaze a bath of fury across Texas as they rob their way to infamy. A silly montage attempts to do the heavy lifting here, and a ridiculous sequence involving a “whites only” train car has some head-scratching, bizarre staging. It’s neither the first nor the last time that Wanted has no idea what to do with its ensemble. They often leave cast members just plopped somewhere on stage, and the less said of the choreography the better. So little care seems to have been given to this element of the show. After two out-of-town tryouts, it’s puzzling how Wanted made it to the Broadway stage in the first place.

The show reaches peak ridiculousness during a musical number that juxtaposes the girls’ grieving mother against a slow-motion burlesque serenade. One gets the feeling they needed to make use of Ledisi, so they get her onstage as much as humanly possible even when it makes little sense to feature her. Thankfully, things do pick back up significantly once Jesse (Bradley Jaden) comes into the picture. The baron takes a liking to Mary, not realizing either of the girls are outlaws or, more substantially, that either of them are black. Jesse claims to have fallen in love with Mary’s kind eyes somehow from a wanted poster. How exactly did he see them on a black silhouette? Jaden makes for some great eye candy that tries hard to distract the audience from how little chemistry most pairings have. The sisters individually aren’t terrible, but they lack a spark to pass as believable relatives.
Servants Sissy (Aurelia Williams) and Flo (Awa Sal Secka) are the standouts of the entire show for me. They play off each other’s energies perfectly, and their quirky comedy and exaggerated expressions are a welcome balm for the unbalanced mess that surrounds them. Though hopes were high for Wanted, it fails to deliver in nearly every regard. The set is too barebones, and both the book and lyrics lack bite. Even the crowd-pleasing final song struggles to overcome its screechy horrors. As much as I wanted to love this unique musical, this is the only time since Mean Girls: The Musical that I’ve actually considered leaving during intermission. A disaster of clashing tones and mismatched vocals, Wanted will leave you wanting a palate cleanser. See Midnight instead.
Wanted: The Musical hunts for outlaws, now playing performances at the James Earl Jones Theatre. For ticketing information, head over to the official website.

