After a years-long dry spell, Johnny Depp is finally back to leave his stamp on another iconic character. Ebenezer Scrooge has been played by everybody from Bill Murray to Jim Carrey and more. We all know the story of A Christmas Carol: Scrooge, an infamous Christmas hater, gets a massive change of heart after being visited by three distinct spirits. What more could there possibly be left to say about a timeless tale that has been retold over and over again? Leave it to Ti West, director of the incredible X horror trilogy, to insert his own twisted stamp on the material. With a darker, horror-tinged take on Scrooge and a committed, vibrant performance from Johnny Depp, Ebenezer is a holiday standout destined for future rewatches.

Seven years after his business partner kicks the bucket, Scrooge has become worse than ever when it comes to communicating with those around him and engaging with his family. The wealthy recluse cares only for his own company and maintaining his massive fortune. Even in the earlier scenes, Ian McKellen and Johnny Depp have great chemistry together that brings to mind Statler and Waldorf from The Muppets. Depp plays his “bah humbug” persona similarly to Jim Carrey, though not quite as exaggerated. His Scrooge comes across as a horrible, uncaring person, making his eventual transformation that much more impactful. As Christmas Day approaches, Scrooge has no intention of visiting his nephew’s home, nor does he care about his coworker’s plight or the homeless in the area. Once alone in his home, the ghost of his old partner, Marley, comes to torment him with Hellraiser-style chains.

The genre influence that Ti West brings to the table is evident from the early scenes, from the way he frames shots to explicit callbacks, including Depp’s own standout death in A Nightmare on Elm Street, where he gets sucked into his bed. Giving this material to a horror director allows the story to lean into its more macabre sensibilities, including garish makeup for each of the ghosts, a distinct gothic style, and a bevy of creepy additions that set Ebenezer apart from the pack. Obviously, there are so many familiar elements here, especially for anyone who has experienced this story in one way or another. All the characters you know and love are still here, albeit in different iterations. The script from Nathaniel Halpern doesn’t stray far from what has already been established narratively. Instead, West allows the performances to do the heavy lifting, paired magnificently with his own sharp eye.
There’s something comforting about sticking so close to the material. A nostalgic, immediately Christmasy tone makes embracing Ebenezer feel like visiting with old friends. A shocking amount of emotionality has been baked right in, from a love story to a familial connection that drove me to tears. For once, though, it’s not Tiny Tim who pushed me to that level. The acting is quite good across the board, with other standouts including Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit and Arthur Conti as a young Ebenezer. The costumes beautifully evoke the 1800s atmosphere, while the brightness of the aftermath stands in stark contrast to the jet-black darkness of Scrooge’s ghostly visitors.

All three Christmas spirits are different enough to stand apart from one another, with Andrea Riseborough’s sunken-eyed ghoul feeling like a deadite straight out of Evil Dead, whereas Tramell Tillman puts an erratic spin on the Ghost of Christmas Present. While Ebenezer might not win over those who already know its themes inside and out, it could introduce an entirely new audience to a fresh classic they’ll want to revisit over and over again. The combination of freakish imagery and a commitment to the original makes for a striking blend of holiday cheer and supernatural horror.
How refreshing to see Johnny Depp in his element, a spot he practically owned throughout the 2000s. At times, the film feels akin to a project Depp would have done with his longtime collaborator, Tim Burton. While West’s approach isn’t quite as stylized as Burton’s, Ebenezer is still overflowing with holiday atmosphere and lovable characters to boot. This crowd-pleasing delight marks Depp’s comeback in a major way, and for that, it should be applauded. God bless us, everyone!
Bah, humbug! Ebenezer is now playing in theaters worldwide.

