In the wake of Harry Potter, many film franchises inspired by young adult novels have attempted to capture similar lightning-in-a-bottle glory. In 2012, The Hunger Games arrived to a flurry of fanfare and instantly catapulted its young cast to breakout success. Over a decade later, it’s hard to believe there is any gas left in the tank. Author Suzanne Collins delivered a fan favorite with last year’s Haymitch prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping. Now, frequent franchise director Francis Lawrence returns to the fray with a bold, exciting adaptation packed with thrills and spectacular performances. Emotionally complex, bleak, utterly devastating, and armed with Joseph Zada’s captivating take on Haymitch, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping proves that this series is destined to stand the test of time.

Every year as the sun rises on Haymitch’s birthday in District 12, a reaping ceremony comes along with it. This barbaric tradition typically “reaps” only one boy and one girl from each district to compete in a battle to the death where there can be only one victor. This year, though, is decidedly different. It’s the second Quarter Quell, an outlier that also came into play in Catching Fire. That means double the tributes, double the carnage, and double Haymitch’s chances of being selected. Nobody hates the Games more than Haymitch’s girlfriend from the Covey, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak). The film takes its first act to establish most of the relationships in Haymitch’s life, including those with his younger brother and loving mother. He has quite a few allies in District 12, and it’s much appreciated that all these relationships are fleshed out before the reaping even happens.

As for the ceremony itself, it unfolds almost exactly as it did in the book. By a cruel twist of fate, Katniss Everdeen found herself volunteering for her first Games. Haymitch’s selection, though, is much more calculated, considering the boy originally selected gets mercilessly killed when he tries to flee. Haymitch’s drive to stand up for the less fortunate becomes a running thread throughout the film. He takes the young Louella (Molly McCann) under his wing, and one of Haymitch’s closest allies becomes the adorable Ampert (Percy Daggs IV), son of Beetee (Kelvin Harrison Jr.). Even the abrasive Maysilee (Mckenna Grace) eventually becomes an ally.
The connections to the larger Hunger Games franchise and its lore are both consistent and seamless. Collins clearly put a lot of thought into weaving together all these interpersonal connections, making it feel less like dreary fan fiction and more like a vibrant, lived-in universe. Thankfully, the film version takes all the right cues from its source material. Every single player has been cast with either a big-name star or an up-and-coming actor more than qualified for the role. Some are only used sparingly. I would have loved to see more of Maya Hawke as Wiress. Others make a meal of their short screentime, including the standout returning character, Effie Trinket. Elle Fanning was practically born to play this role, and she’s absolutely flawless here. Glenn Close plays a horrific precursor to Effie, with her garish looks, extravagant outfits, and general disgust for District 12. As President Snow, Ralph Fiennes was a solid choice, given his tenure as Harry Potter‘s central He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named villain. His Snow is calculated and evil, a natural extension of Tom Blyth’s portrayal in The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes. Similarly, Plutarch feels very close to his original incarnation, which is a pleasant surprise given that Jesse Plemons, on paper, doesn’t physically resemble the late, great Philip Seymour Hoffman. Plemons has a substantial amount to do within the framework of the story, and is always up to the task. Kieran Culkin also sasses it up as Caesar Flickerman.

The younger newcomers, though, are arguably Sunrise on the Reaping‘s greatest asset. Mckenna Grace as Maysilee delivers an edgy, somehow lovable tribute. Ben Wang brings a tenderness to his Wyatt. But the biggest knockout performance comes courtesy of Australian actor Joseph Zada. Zada surprised me with his layered turn in the underrated series Invisible Boys. He brings that same level of nuance and vulnerability to Haymitch, echoing Woody Harrelson’s previous spin on the character. But Zada makes this portrayal his own, delivering a teary-eyed, deeply human version of Haymitch who wears his heart on his sleeve. The film’s success rests almost entirely on Zada’s shoulders, which could have been a massive miscalculation had the actor not been up to the task. As it stands, he remains a perfect casting choice. The curly-haired, blue-eyed blond is so much more than a bit of eye candy. As Haymitch systematically loses those he loves, it’s Zada’s natural charisma and chemistry with the cast that charge these moments with an emotional sucker punch. Of course, much of the impact can also be attributed to an exceptional score by composer James Newton Howard, buoyed by Lawrence’s stealthy directorial eye.
Once we get into the arena, the action and thrills always come secondary to character development and the larger narrative arc at play. Those hoping for a nonstop action extravaganza should probably look elsewhere. That said, this entry absolutely bears the most in common with Catching Fire, the best book and film of the series. Sunrise on the Reaping has a different kind of feel to it, though, telling a story steeped in tragedy that is nonetheless necessary to bring everything full circle. In the closing moments, the entire series comes into play. Sunrise on the Reaping presents itself as a love letter to what came before, a devoted final brushstroke on a masterful franchise that has plenty to say about war, grief, and loss. Its heaviness and pervasive sense of danger underline the dangers of war, and its countless casualties. Collins’ views on the subject are baked right in, and Lawrence and screenwriters Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie encapsulate her prose in a more abbreviated fashion. Of course, plenty is left on the cutting room floor, and devoted book lovers looking for a direct, one-to-one adaptation should probably adjust their expectations. Until the franchise inevitably gets a television series extension of some kind, the cinematic retellings of these stories still hold plenty of power.

The performances alone are awards worthy, while the production design and visual effects offer a veritable cornucopia of spectacle. Even at nearly three hours, the only complaint I could level at the film is that the final act perhaps moves a little too quickly. I would love to see an even longer version, and hopefully an extended cut could be in the cards once it comes to home video. But as it stands, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is another stunning film in a nearly flawless franchise. Though targeted at young adults, its messaging is timeless, and its performances are pure gold.
Without getting into spoilers, each instance in which Lenore Dove speaks of the ones we love merely moving on to another world is comforting and sweet. These sentiments add further depth to both Lenore’s character and Haymitch’s poignant arc. Zada and the cast no doubt have plenty of future films ahead of them, yet Sunrise on the Reaping will always be a special, impactful addition to their filmographies. Wildly entertaining and emotionally devastating, Sunrise on the Reaping lives up to The Hunger Games and then some. It’s a veritable feast all on its own, one that will leave you hungry to revisit the world of Panem again and again.
Go back in time to experience the bleak horrors of Haymitch’s backstory with The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, now playing in theaters worldwide.

